Lobby Watch 27 February 2019
A multi-millionaire pro-Israel lobbyist is funding the UK Parliament’s new Independent Group, it was revealed this week.
Others are likely to follow.
David Garrard told newspapers he had already donated to the MPs who broke away from the opposition Labour Party and the ruling Conservative Party.
The Independent Group is expected to eventually register as a party.
Garrard has for many years been a major financial backer of Labour Friends of Israel, a front group for the Israeli embassy, and was recently appointed to its board.
Prior to left-wing Palestine solidarity activist Jeremy Corbyn becoming party leader in 2015, Garrard donated almost $2 million to Labour under former leaders Tony Blair, Gordon Brown and Ed Miliband.
Garrard was so dismayed after Corbyn’s leadership election in September 2015, that he called in a loan of more than $2.5 million he had made to the party.
Despite this, Labour was last year reported to be Britain’s richest party, thanks to a massive influx of members enthused by Corbyn’s popular, moderately socialist agenda.
Despite leaving the party, Garrard has continued to fund individual anti-Corbyn MPs within Labour.
The Independent Group was formed last week by eight Labour MPs who quit the party, while alleging that Labour is now “institutionally anti-Semitic.”
While they were still in Labour, Garrard funded two of these eight.
Campaigning against Corbyn
The “moderate” faction was soon joined by three defecting Conservatives who agree with the group’s anti-Brexit stance.
Ian Austin, another anti-Corbyn MP, also quit Labour last week. But he has not formally joined the Independent Group, as he disagrees with its views on Brexit.
Garrard has also donated almost $28,000 since May 2016 to Austin – a leading supporter of Labour Friends of Israel.
As Austin explained to Sky News, “I’ve been campaigning against Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership for years.”
The majority of the Independent Group remain part of Labour Friends of Israel – despite no longer being members of the Labour Party.
Labour Friends of Israel’s chair Joan Ryan resigned from Labour a week ago citing Corbyn’s “hatred for Israel” and alleged failure to combat anti-Semitism.
Along with Ryan, the Independent Group MPs still listed as supporters of Labour Friends of Israel are: Luciana Berger, Mike Gapes, Chris Leslie, Angela Smith and Chuka Umunna.
Before she first entered Parliament in 2010, Berger for years worked as the director of Labour Friends of Israel.
The official register of donations to members of Parliament shows that in 2016 and 2017, Garrard donated almost $9,000 to Ryan and more than $50,000 to Chuka Umunna and his office.
Umunna is currently being touted as a possible new leader of the Independent Group.
The latest register shows Garrard has also donated almost $20,000 to deputy Labour Party leader Tom Watson – who has long opposed Corbyn.
Garrard, a property tycoon, told The Sunday Telegraph and The Observer this weekend that he had “already done so” when asked if he would financially back the new Independent Group.
Labour has “been hijacked by an ultra-left cabal” who want to “turn our nation into a socialist republic,” he claimed. He also repeated the right-wing smears about alleged anti-Semitism that have dogged Labour for nearly four years.
Another millionaire former Labour donor signaled his intention to switch his financial backing to the new group this weekend.
Michael Foster, who was suspended from Labour in 2016 for abusing Corbyn and his team as Nazis, told The Sunday Telegraph of the new group that he “would support them in any way that I could.”
Other Israel lobby funders seem likely to follow Garrard.
The Sunday Times this weekend named Trevor Chinn and Jonathan Goldstein as two other “potential donors” to the group – although it cited no evidence.
Chinn is one of the leaders of BICOM and Goldstein is chair of the Jewish Leadership Council – both are British pro-Israel lobby groups.
Chinn donated more than $6,000 to Labour Friends of Israel’s chair Joan Ryan in 2017.
He donated a similar amount to deputy Labour leader Tom Watson in 2018.
Although the Independent Group has signaled its ultimate intention to set up a new political party, it is not yet registered as one.
Even though most voters in practice vote for a party rather than individual MPs, there is no requirement that lawmakers who quit their party resign their seats in Parliament and stand in a by-election.
Historically, however, some MPs who left their parties have chosen to resign.
But the Independent Group’s MPs have rejected calls that they resign and seek re-election, with one ironically justifying this refusal to face a democratic vote because it would supposedly “crush the birth of democracy.”
Garrard quit Labour in April 2018.
More than a decade ago, he was embroiled in the “cash for peerages” scandal during the government of Tony Blair.
Garrard was one of four controversial names nominated by Blair to be “life peers” in the House of Lords, the UK’s unelected upper chamber.
The four were rejected, and it was later revealed they had previously loaned millions to the Labour Party, raising the question of whether they had effectively paid for the nominations.
Garrard denied any wrongdoing. Although Blair was questioned three times by police, and two of his aides were arrested, no one was ever charged with a crime.
Israeli embassy front group
These revelations about Israel lobby funding for the new group come soon after speculation by some in Labour of Israeli involvement in the splinter group.
Ruth George, a Labour MP, was forced to apologize after reports on a Facebook comment thread in which she had stated that “support from the state of Israel” for the new group “is possible” and that she “would not condemn those who suggest it, especially when the group’s financial backers are not being revealed.”
In 2017, an undercover investigation by Al Jazeera revealed that Labour Friends of Israel is effectively a front for the Israeli embassy.
One of the group’s staff privately admitted that, although “publicly we just try to keep the LFI as a separate identity to the embassy,” they work “really closely together.”
Labour Friends of Israel chair Joan Ryan would speak to Israeli embassy agent Shai Masot “most days,” he said.
The documentary also revealed that the Israeli embassy was trying to engineer the creation of a “Young Labour Friends of Israel” grouping within the UK’s main opposition party, to counteract strong grassroots support for Palestinian rights.
Shai Masot was expelled from the UK after the scandal broke in 2017.
More recently, Israel has used its Act.IL app to stoke opposition to Corbyn, accusing him of anti-Semitism and falsely claiming he had compared Israel to Nazi Germany.
Meanwhile, Joan Ryan remains Labour Friends of Israel’s chair despite quitting the Labour party.
- Independent Group
- Labour Friends of Israel
- David Garrard
- Israeli embassy in London
- Labour Party
- Conservative Party
- Jeremy Corbyn
- Tony Blair
- Gordon Brown
- Ed Miliband
- Ian Austin
- Joan Ryan
- Luciana Berger
- Mike Gapes
- Chris Leslie
- Angela Smith
- Chuka Umunna
- Tom Watson
- Michael Foster
- Trevor Chinn
- Jonathan Goldstein
- Jewish Leadership Council
- House of Lords
- Ruth George
- Shai Masot
- Michael Rubin
- Labour witch hunt
The Corbyn anti-Semitic pantomime
Permalink Rusty replied on
Obviously the flawed - and false - accusation (slur) that Corbyn and Labour are 'institutionally anti-Semitic' critically avoids reflection on the fact Corbyn is 'institutionally pro-Palestinian' and censorious of Zionist Israel's illegal settlements and continuing land thefts - of the human rights abuses and war crimes visited daily on the hapless heads of the Palestininan 'Semite' populations of the ever-diminishing occupied West Bank - and Gaza Strip - the latter besieged behind Israel's 30-odd foot high Great Apartheid Wall - inside the biggest concentration camp on the planet.
Labour Party 'Antisemitism'
Permalink Andrew replied on
Chris Williamson latest victim of the zionist thought police. It seems that you don't actually have to break the IHRA rules- just say something about the witch hunt. Tom Watson should go, he really does like to put the boot in when he can. Chris Williamson was also apparently in trouble for screening a film about Jackie Walker in the House of Commons.
Permalink john blacker replied on
Finally we expose these secret operators pretending to be anything other than enemies of democracy.
As these criminals and confidence crooks no longer represent the manifestos of which they stood to ask for votes - are they not therefore compelled to stand for re-election on the new manifesto they have been given by their paymaster?
Its a bit like buying a tin of corned beef and taking it home to find its full of sweaty fish.
Permalink Eric replied on
Good riddance to these Quislings and their tainted money.
How can they remain in "Labour" Friends of Zionism if they're no longer in Labour?
And how can LFI carry on if its chief agent, Joan Ryan, is no longer in Labour?
Permalink eGuard replied on
No need to ask Ryan to give up the LFI chair. Nor should LFI interfere. It's just: all other Labour members should resign from LFI. You know, show colours.
UN Report on Human Rights abuses published today
Permalink Chris Friel replied on
The UN published their report on the Gaza killings today. (Just to offer a perspective on what the lobby is for):
Labour Friends of Israel are
Permalink Michael Morgan replied on
Labour Friends of Israel are an organisation funded by a foreign power with the sole objective of validating the racist, apartheid crimes of Israel.
They are ideologically incompatible with the values of the Party, valuing as they do the illegal occupation, the use of force against unarmed protesters, the imprisonment of children and war crimes against the Palestinian people.
The Labour Party has NO room for this organisation which, by its own admission works to destabilise the Party and interfere with its democratic processes and policies.
As an organisation it must be proscribed and any foreign funding sources should be rejected immediately.
Your Suspension from Labour Party...
Permalink YannisH replied on
...is because you are an excellent Journalist as this piece shows. Hope you are back in LP soon. But anyway we need your Journalism in or out of the Party.
The Telegraph reports that
Permalink tom hall replied on
The Telegraph reports that property tycoon David Garrard has donated £1.5 million to the "Independent Group". That ought to buy a lot of independence.
Permalink Paul Cardin replied on
Recent unreported events on Wirral indicate there is a "safe space" created for other parties to engage in anti-Semitism.