A leaked internal report shows that the UK Labour Party’s bureaucrats conspired to undermine their own leader Jeremy Corbyn from the start, even sabotaging the 2017 general election campaign.
It also reveals how Labour’s left-wing leaders came to embrace the right’s witch hunt against members over the manufactured anti-Semitism crisis.
The document shows that right-wingers at Labour headquarters, led by former general secretary Iain McNicol, orchestrated “a hyper-factional atmosphere” against Corbyn.
The report describes a “purge” of Corbyn-supporting party members.
You can read pages from the leaked document below.
“The content and the release of the report into the public domain raise a number of matters of serious concern,” he said.
From the moment Corbyn first won the leadership in 2015, the report shows, left-wing members were obsessively demonized as “Trots” – slang for a faction of communists. Many were expelled or suspended on flimsy pretexts – including false accusations of anti-Semitism.
One senior Labour Press officer privately described Corbyn as “that fucking Trot” and said that some MPs who nominated him for leader deserved “to be taken out and shot.”
A Labour staffer described the atmosphere at headquarters: “everyone else is much more right-wing” and considers anyone to the left of former Prime Minister Gordon Brown “to be a Trot.”
The internal sabotage of Corbyn included budgeting $280,000 for a “secret key seats” project allegedly intended to “funnel additional resources into seats of key figures on the right of the party.”
This confirms what The Electronic Intifada reported at the time: “Labour Party headquarters had funnelled campaign resources away from seats being contested by pro-Corbyn candidates and towards so-called ‘moderates.’”
The report does not mention these candidates by name, however.
Ryan worked to undermine Corbyn. Despite “misgivings about the Labour leadership,” Ryan wrote to her constituents, “I hope that you will consider voting for me as your local MP.”
Yet despite such efforts, Corbyn did much better than expected, giving Labour its best result for years and denying the ruling Conservative Party a majority.
The leak shows that one senior Labour staffer was furious at voters: “The people have spoken. Bastards.”
The leaked internal report concludes there was “no evidence” Labour staff have been motivated by anti-Semitism, or that complaints about anti-Semitism were treated differently from others.
After Corbyn, a lifelong Palestine solidarity campaigner, became leader in 2015, pro-Israel groups relentlessly attacked him and his supporters as anti-Semitic.
This defamation campaign ultimately succeeded. The “crisis” was a top focus during the 2019 general election, and polling showed that Corbyn’s mishandling of it was one of the top five reasons for voters not supporting Labour.
The Israel lobby declared victory, with one group claiming to have “slaughtered” Corbyn.
Despite all this, and the misleading nature of most of these attacks, Corbyn, to his own ruin, embraced the very same groups that were promoting the “crisis” lies.
The leaked document was also passed around among journalists and Labour members.
In 851 pages of often tedious detail, the report examines the work of the party’s disciplinary unit around anti-Semitism between 2014 and 2019.
It was written as part of Labour’s response to the investigation of the party launched last May by the Equality and Human Rights Commission.
But the document reportedly will not now be submitted to the body, after Keir Starmer took over as leader.
A Labour Party staffer told The Electronic Intifada that colleagues had “vanished for literally months on end” to work on the report. The source predicted that the new Labour leader would now use the leak to clean out the current Labour staff.
The Commission, the UK’s official anti-discrimination body, has come under criticism after launching its investigation into alleged anti-Semitism in Labour at the request of two pro-Israel groups – the Jewish Labour Movement and the Campaign Against Antisemitism.
The Campaign Against Antisemitism is the one that later claimed to have “slaughtered” Corbyn.
But the leaked report shows the extent to which Corbyn and his team capitulated to the lobby’s demands, in the forlorn hope its campaign against him would stop.
The report repeatedly attacks some of Corbyn’s high-profile supporters, several pushed out of the party after being smeared as anti-Semites.
Those again smeared in the document include former London mayor Ken Livingstone, anti-racist activists Jackie Walker and Marc Wadsworth, left-wing former Labour lawmaker Chris Williamson, Jewish anti-Zionist Tony Greenstein and this writer.
A farcical example of the document’s conflation of criticism of Israel with anti-Jewish racism comes in its section on me.
The report in most cases does not explain or offer evidence as to why the acts of these “high profile” individuals were supposedly anti-Semitic. It merely asserts that they are.
A “joint meeting”
Corbyn, Formby and their staff repeatedly intervened to speed up disciplinary action in some “high profile” cases of smeared activists – often at the insistence of the Jewish Labour Movement.
“After Jennie Formby was appointed general secretary in March 2018, action on anti-Semitism complaints increased dramatically,” the authors contend.
Corbyn and Formby’s commitment to obeying the dictates of the Israel lobby even extended to Labour Friends of Israel – which functions as a front for the Israeli embassy.
An April 2018 email from Corbyn shows he discussed setting up a “joint meeting” between Labour Friends of Palestine and Labour Friends of Israel to “agree on [a] two-state statement on Israel-Palestine.”
The report’s authors took the email as proof of Corbyn’s “desire for the party to lead on tackling anti-Semitism and racism.”
It is yet more evidence of Corbyn and Formby’s muddled and self-defeating approach that cosying up to the Israel lobby would help them fight the false allegations of anti-Jewish animus.
Labour factionalism and right-wing racism
The report appears to be an effort to exonerate the current Labour general secretary Jennie Formby and the cadre of bureaucrats around her, while attacking their internal enemies.
A main target is Sam Matthews, a former party bureaucrat.
Matthews and other right-wing Labour staffers eventually quit their jobs at party headquarters.
He asserted in the film that he was “heartbroken and disgusted that the party I joined over a decade ago is now institutionally racist.”
But internal Labour Party emails and conversations in WhatsApp groups contained in the leaked report show that Matthews and other right-wing bureaucrats actively worked to sabotage Corbyn from the start.
Dan Hogan, another right-wing bureaucrat who appeared in the Panorama film as a “whistleblower,” had in September 2015 reacted with violent contempt to a visit by the party’s new leader to headquarters.
A staffer who “whooped” for Corbyn’s speech “should be shot,” wrote Hogan.
“Massive elephant in the room that we all kind of hate” Corbyn, a colleague responded.
Other staffers deployed anti-Black stereotypes against Diane Abbott, calling her an “angry woman” and “truly repulsive.”
The UK’s first Black female member of parliament, Abbott was one of Corbyn’s few supporters among Labour lawmakers.
Who wrote it?
The leaked document’s metadata suggests the report’s lead author was Harry Hayball, a current Labour Party staffer.
Written over several months following Labour’s defeat in December’s election, the report took a dozen staffers to prepare.
Hayball was recruited by Labour in 2019 to exclusively work on anti-Semitism.
He previously worked on the same topic for Momentum, the Labour organization forged by Jon Lansman after the original Jeremy For Leader campaign.
As part of this work, Hayball met the Jewish Labour Movement and other groups to discuss “tackling anti-Semitism within the party and on the left,” the report states.
A second staffer recruited under Formby specifically to work on anti-Semitism was Patrick Smith.
Smith quit the group in 2013, but still toed their line, describing Palestine Solidarity Campaign activists as “essentially mad.”
The report spins this history, claiming instead that Smith was “hired specifically because of his knowledge of anti-Semitism and the forms it takes on the left.”
“Smith had been a member of the Palestine Solidarity Campaign, but he left the organization in 2008,” over alleged anti-Semitism, the report asserts.
Witch hunt against left
The document also alleges that right-wing Labour staffers’ obsession with purging “Trots” meant that they often missed or delayed work on the small number of credible complaints about anti-Semitism.
The authors suggest that some staffers may have “failed to act on extreme cases of anti-Semitism in order to undermine the Labour Party as led by Jeremy Corbyn.”
They also speculate that “staff were simply not motivated to deal with such cases properly, and that they were only motivated to work on things that contained a factional element.”
Despite these admissions of bias, the report ignores how many of the complaints involved politically motivated false charges echoing Israel lobby smears of the left and Palestine solidarity campaigners.
The authors even denounce reporting of how smears have been used against campaigners as anti-Semitism “denialism.”
Indeed, the authors enthusiastically contribute towards this smear campaign.
The leaked report states that former staffers neglected a complaint of alleged anti-Semitism against Labour members in the constituency Louise Ellman then represented in Parliament.
But they ignore how the allegations against the local party branch, Liverpool Riverside, were part of a political witch hunt against the left.
The Jewish Chronicle’s reporting of the alleged anti-Semitism in the constituency was ruled by the UK’s press regulator last year to be “significantly misleading.”
After a libel suit, the paper settled out of court with local activist Audrey White, admitting that it had published allegations about her that were “untrue.”
- Labour witch hunt
- Jeremy Corbyn
- Labour Party
- Jennie Formby
- Iain McNicol
- Harry Hayball
- Labour Friends of Israel
- Labour Friends of Palestine
- Jewish Labour Movement
- Sam Matthews
- Keir Starmer
- Gordon Brown
- Joan Ryan
- Jeremy Newmark
- Palestine Solidarity Campaign
- Campaign Against Antisemitism
- Sky News
- Novara Media
- Al Jazeera
- Ken Livingstone
- Marc Wadsworth
- Jackie Walker
- Tony Greenstein
- Chris Williamson
- Asa Winstanley
- Louise Ellman
- Dan Hogan
- Diane Abbott
- Jon Lansman
- Patrick Smith
- Alliance for Workers' Liberty
- Liverpool Riverside
- Audrey White
- Equality and Human Rights Commission