Media Watch 19 March 2023
Owen Jones, Martin Forde and Aaron Bastani. (Bokmässan/Al Jazeera/BBC)
The senior British lawyer whose inquiry into Labour Party racism concluded that anti-Semitism allegations had been “weaponized” against former left-wing leader Jeremy Corbyn has finally spoken to the media.
“Anti-Black racism, Islamophobia isn’t taken as seriously as anti-Semitism” in Labour, Martin Forde told Al Jazeera on Thursday.
Forde spoke to Al Jazeera’s investigative unit in a new episode of The Labour Files series released online. You can watch the whole interview in the video below.
The interview has prompted increased criticism of Labour from some of the small cohort of liberals passing for “leftists” permitted to have a mainstream profile in British media – such as Owen Jones and Aaron Bastani.
But grassroots former Labour activists have been criticizing the liberals for their belated response to the issue when it is too late to make a difference to Corbyn’s electoral chances.Back when Corbyn was still Labour leader and had a shot at becoming prime minister, these same people were actively promoting the fabricated “anti-Semitism crisis.”
As The Electronic Intifada has reported for years, during his time as leader Corbyn was subjected to an unprecedented disinformation campaign – often led by Israel and its lobby – falsely painting the party as having a massive and unique “anti-Semitism problem.”
In reality, the problem from the pro-Israel perspective was the party grassroots’ strong solidarity with Palestine.
Media blackout
In the interview Forde said he had heard almost nothing from Labour since his inquiry published its findings and a detailed series of recommendations in July last year.
New leader Keir Starmer even promised to take steps to tackle racism in Labour following the report.
Forde told the Qatar-based channel that this was “not in my view a sufficient response” to his inquiry, which detailed serious allegations of racism among senior party staff targeting Black pro-Corbyn MPs like Diane Abbott.
Forde also revealed that not a single media outlet has interviewed him since his inquiry concluded. “I think I was approached by one on the day of publication, but they … hadn’t actually read the report. And I suggested they might want to do that first and they didn’t come back to me.”
The media blackout on the Forde report was in stark contrast to the five years of incessant coverage of “anti-Semitism” allegations in the Labour Party when it was led by Jeremy Corbyn.
Such allegations were more often than not concocted by pro-Israel lobbyists to attack Corbyn – a Palestine solidarity activist – and his left-wing supporters.
BBC pressure
Not only did the mainstream media completely blank the Forde report, but the BBC actively attempted to censor it.
The report concluded that one part of the BBC’s 2019 Panorama program about the supposed Labour anti-Semitism crisis had been “entirely misleading.”
Forde revealed on Thursday that, soon after the publication of his findings, both Panorama’s editor and its lead reporter John Ware wrote letters asking him to change his report to remove this conclusion.
Forde appears to have declined or ignored these requests – as of this writing the conclusion remains in the report still on the Labour Party’s website.
Panorama editor Karen Wightman wrote to Forde in September asking him to “consider amending your report” and contesting its characterization of her program as misleading.
Ware wrote to Forde insisting that: “Your report has done significant damage to my reputation and to that of the Corporation [BBC] for journalistic integrity.” He wrote a series of questions to Forde and asked him “to respond by 4pm tomorrow 11 October.”
Forde’s Al Jazeera interview this week prompted renewed interest in the Panorama episode, which has come under increased criticism from left-wing activists in recent months – the same people who were so often falsely smeared as anti-Semitic due to their support for Corbyn.
Establishment “leftists”
But renewed attention on the Forde report and criticism of the Panorama episode has also included those few supposed “leftists” who are regularly given platforms in the mainstream UK media, or were during the Corbyn years – the same people who ended up attacking or turning against the Corbyn leadership, often over the false “anti-Semitism crisis.”
This week those included Guardian columnists Owen Jones and George Monbiot, as well as Novara Media co-founder Aaron Bastani.Jones and Monbiot both ended up opposing the Corbyn leadership, while Bastani and Novara frequently indulged and promoted media lies about “left-wing anti-Semitism” in Corbyn’s Labour.
But now all three appear to want to win back lost credibility among their audiences by finally questioning the Panorama narrative – four years on – and calling for something to be done by Labour on the Forde report.
Meanwhile they fail to accept responsibility for promoting the false anti-Semitism narrative in the first place.
Left-wing activists and commentators this week castigated Jones, Monbiot and Bastani:
Owen Jones has been notoriously opportunistic and has regularly flip-flopped on issues related to Israel, alleged anti-Semitism and Corbyn.He has embraced Zionism, spoken in favor of the pro-Israel lobby, driven the Labour membership purge of the pro-Palestinian left and even whitewashed a Zionist collaborator with the Nazis.
Although Jones was promoted by British mainstream media as a supporter of Corbyn, his support was always half-hearted at best. Jones ditched Corbyn during the 2016 coup attempt by the Labour Party establishment – a position he later admitted was “wrong.”
In his 2020 book This Land, Jones admitted to participating in various coup attempts against Corbyn, writing that he wanted to have him replaced with soft-left MP and former soldier Clive Lewis, later pushing for his former boss and pro-NATO lawmaker John McDonnell to take over.
Meanwhile George Monbiot abandoned any pretense of support for Corbyn back in 2017, joining in with the “anti-Semitism” witch-hunters at the height of the manufactured crisis in 2018.
For his part, Bastani and the rest of his Novara colleagues constantly threw the victims of the “anti-Semitism” witch hunt under the bus, including former London mayor Ken Livingstone, Black Jewish anti-racism activist Jackie Walker and former lawmaker Chris Williamson – even this reporter has been falsely smeared, without evidence, as “anti-Semitic” by Novara’s Michael Walker.Appearing on the BBC’s This Week program in 2018, Bastani vigorously agreed with presenter Andrew Neil and fellow guest Robert Winston – a celebrity TV doctor and anti-Palestinian activist – that “anti-Semitism” was “endemic” in Corbyn’s Labour.
This was at the height of the fabricated “anti-Semitism crisis” in Labour in 2018. But instead of pushing back Bastani used a major mainstream media appearance to promote the “crisis.”Bastani and the rest of the anarchists at Novara in large part launched their high-profile media careers off the back of their ostensible support for the mass movement that brought Corbyn to the Labour leadership – only to stab it in the back when it counted.
With friends like these, who needs enemies?
Comments
Thanks - great article
Permalink SM replied on
Great to read your analysis. I’ve felt so confused by the participation of left wing figures in the obviously manufactured anti-sensitise crisis, and the clear hierarchy of racism - I wondered if I was losing the plot. I joined Labour when I saw how JC was getting the full establishment disinformation campaign.
I left when he was booted out on the back of obvious lies. But it was hard to work out Nidhi was missing something. Seems not. Thank you.
anarchists
Permalink jon brown replied on
I think its an odd stretch to describe either Walker or Bastani as anarchists. And an insult to anarchists. Bastani is a practicing Christian married to a labour party activist. Both are supportive of momentum. A great article otherwise Asa. Its nice to have all these past rotten behaviors chronicaled in one place.
One wonders how many of these
Permalink James replied on
One wonders how many of these two-faced individuals have been or still are working for intelligence agencies. Their pathologically dishonest behaviour seems like more than just flip-flopping.
Jeremy Corbyn's biggest enemy...
Permalink Sam A. replied on
... during the entire "antisemitism false charge era" was..
Jeremy Corbyn.
Had the man called all of his banners to battle at the beginning of it all, and nipped it in the bud, chances were good that he could have defeated and hobbled his opposition, and came charging out of that entire debacle with a head of steam.
Instead, he folded like a cheap suit, threw his own lieutenants under the bus, and tucked tail and ran.
agreed
Permalink Jonathan Coulter replied on
I agree with this comment. Although a strong supporter of Palestinian rights and an opponent of our nonsensical middle eastern wars, Jeremy Corbyn did not show necessary qualites of a political leader. Yes, he folded.
Asa, this is great, but not just a problem for left-wing navels
Permalink Jonathan Coulter replied on
Asa, it is great the way you meticulously document the dishonesty and opportunism of this "fake media left". But your this is not a uniquely left-wing problem. Such chameleons exist in other parties and institutions and have been instrumental in sustaining false narratives about antisemitism in the Labour Party and other parts of British society. You have "alternative" newspaper outlets that religiously pursue the "progressive-except-on-Palestine" approach. Within another political party, I have witnessed "Friends of Palestine" who resisted to the hilt taking any determined action to head off adoption of the IHRA definition, and a leadership that has enforced censorship of discussion as to the veracity or otherwise of accusations against the Labour left. You have dissident Tories like Sir Alan Duncan who was targeted for his bold stand in support of the Palestinians, but never showed the slightest sympathy for those tarred and feathered on the other side of the political spectrum. We need a national conversation about the morality of this, as CAMPAIN has started in its Open Letter to the Church of England: https://www.campain.org/open-l...