Lobby Watch 25 October 2016
A notorious anti-Black and Islamophobic group has launched a national offensive against students and professors associated with the movement for Palestinian rights.
Beginning earlier this month, posters placed by the David Horowitz Freedom Center appeared at San Francisco State University, the University of Tennessee, Tufts University, Vassar College, the University of Chicago, the City University of New York’s Brooklyn College, San Diego State University and the University of California’s Irvine, Berkeley and Los Angeles campuses.
The posters feature cartoon portraits of the named students or professors they’re targeting, next to a list of allegations, followed by the hashtag “#JewHatred.”
Though they include some innocuous labels, such as “BDS activist” or “SJP activist,” the posters also include defamatory charges.
For example, Professor Rabab Abdulhadi of San Francisco State University is called “a leader of the Hamas BDS campaign” and a “collaborator with terrorists.”
Hatem Bazian who teaches at UC Berkeley is called a “supporter of Hamas terrorists” and an “Islamophobia alarmist.”
Among the campaign’s unsupported claims is that American Muslims for Palestine, a group founded by Bazian, has been funneling “terrorist dollars” to Students for Justice in Palestine groups to support the “Hamas-sponsored” BDS movement.
Spreading fear and hate
The David Horowitz Freedom Center has claimed credit for the campaign.
The Southern Poverty Law Center, which monitors hate groups and extremism, says that since the 1980s the group’s founder, David Horowitz, has “become a driving force of the anti-Muslim, anti-immigrant and anti-Black movements.”
Horowitz’s organization has also “become the premier financier of anti-Muslim voices and radical ideologies, as well as acting as an exporter of misinformation that seeks to increase popular appeal for Horowitz’s fears and phobias,” according to the Southern Poverty Law Center.
Horowitz’s posters credit Canary Mission, a website that blacklists students and teachers who criticize Israel, for information.
Horowitz appears to have piloted his campaign in April when similar posters turned up on the UCLA campus.
At the time, UCLA vice chancellor Jerry Kang sharply denounced the posters as “a serious escalation” and promised that the university would “deploy all lawful resources to counter any harassment or intimidation.”
Kang has now become a target in Horowitz’s renewed poster campaign.
San Francisco State University president Leslie Wong condemned Horowitz’ posters on 14 October, the day they appeared on campus, but some students and faculty say he has not gone far enough.
Wong said he was “angered” by the “vandalism” on campus, calling the posters a “hateful attack.” He blamed “an outside extremist group,” but did not name Horowitz.
“This is not an issue of free speech; this is bullying behavior that is unacceptable and will not be tolerated on our campus,” Wong added.
Campus police have opened an investigation.
“We do not endorse the message, and consistent with principles of free speech, we believe that the most powerful response to speech that divides or degrades people is more speech which promotes inclusion, advances human dignity, and encourages mutually respectful actions and communications,” San Francisco State University spokesperson Elizabeth Smith told The Electronic Intifada.
She said the investigation would review how widespread the activity was and whether any school policies were violated.
But Joanne Barker, a professor of American Indian Studies, believes Wong should have named the Horowitz organization and exposed the racist intentions of the campaign.
“In moments like what happened last week where you have non-response response, it doesn’t make me feel safe as a university employee,” Barker said.
She noted that the FBI defines vandalism as a hate crime when it contains the added element of bias.
Barker said that the university “should be contacting federal and state authorities to investigate this incident as a hate crime.”
After the posters went up, the General Union of Palestine Students called an emergency meeting on campus, attended by representatives of other student organizations and communities.
Rex Halafihi was the first student to see the posters when he arrived on campus at 7:30am on Friday morning.
“It’s funny how media is congratulating Wong. His email is so vague and doesn’t actually condemn David Horowitz or Canary Mission or talk about how they’re anti-Muslim organizations,” Halafihi said. “It’s just so ridiculous.”
Silence at Irvine
The legal defense group Palestine Legal urged UC Irvine chancellor Howard Gillman to publicly condemn the posters.
But administrators have yet to do so. UC Irvine spokesperson Cathy Lawhon told The Electronic Intifada that the posters were removed within two hours of being put up and as a result the school received no complaints from students.
Palestine Legal reminded Gillman that, in contrast to his silence now, he has been quick to propagate what turned out to be false accusations against student activists for Palestinian rights.
“Our universities are anti-free speech and they support terrorists,” Horowitz told The Electronic Intifada. “I want people to know that you guys – The Electronic Intifada included – are part of a terrorist campaign to destroy the State of Israel and kill the Jews – and Americans as well.”
When asked for evidence that Students for Justice in Palestine groups were funded by Hamas or “terrorist” groups, Horowitz pointed to a document on his website that purports to connect the dots from SJP to “terrorists” and Hamas.
But the only loose connection Horowitz draws is between American Muslims for Palestine and individuals formerly involved in the Holy Land Foundation.
In a highly politicized trial, the US prosecuted five men who worked for the charity on charges of “material support for terrorism,” even though the US had provided funding to the same organizations in the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip as the Holy Land Foundation.
Horowitz told The Electronic Intifada that Students for Justice in Palestine tells “huge lies,” like “Israel occupies Arab lands.”
“Palestinians are a completely invented nationalism,” he added. “It’s ridiculous. Israel is the only state in the Middle East that’s not apartheid.”
Abdulhadi, the main target of the posters at San Francisco State University, says that it is past time for Wong’s administration to stand squarely behind those who have been subjected to a long harassment campaign.
“Well-funded groups are trying to undermine us because they know if the discussion happens more and more people are more likely to join the world community in supporting Palestine,” Abdulhadi told The Electronic Intifada.
Two years ago, anti-Palestinian organizations AMCHA, the Simon Wiesenthal Center, StandWithUs, the Zionist Organization of America and Scholars for Peace in the Middle East accused Abdulhadi of meeting with “terrorists” and asked the university to investigate her.
The university found the allegations had no merit, and that the alleged activity was part of her scholarship.
Nonetheless, Abdulhadi believes the administration’s weak responses have emboldened the groups to escalate their attacks.
Zionist groups are currently targeting the partnership Abdulhadi recently brokered between San Francisco State University and An-Najah National University in Nablus in the occupied West Bank.
For Abdulhadi, the dearth of support amid the mounting intimidation campaign is compounded by what she says is the university’s failure to fulfill its commitments to Muslim and Arab ethnic studies programs.
Following a student hunger strike last spring in response to proposed cuts to the budget for ethnic studies, the administration renewed its promises to hire two more professors.
- David Horowitz
- David Horowitz Freedom Center
- San Francisco State University
- University of California
- University of Tennessee
- Tufts University
- Vassar College
- University of Chicago
- Brooklyn College
- San Diego State University
- UC Irvine
- UC Berkeley
- rabab abdulhadi
- Hatem Bazian
- American Muslims for Palestine
- Southern Poverty Law Center
- Canary Mission
- Jerry Kang
- Leslie Wong
- Palestine Legal
- Howard Gillman
- Holy Land 5
- An-Najah University
These co-ordinated attacks need a more co-ordinated response
Permalink Russell Ward replied on
I'm all for free speech, but the San Francisco State University administration is not exercising its freedom to state more forcefully how this national poster campaign targeting faculty and students as supporters of terrorism is a threat to the safety of individuals and academic freedom. Given the coordinated nature of this attack, wouldn't it be appropriate for administrations from all all affected universities and academic bodies more generally issue a coordinated response? And should not the context of these attacks, including instances like the suspension of a student course on Israeli settler colonialism, be investigated and evidence of the involvement of the Israeli government and their funded proxies be called out?
Hell, if these hateful attacks were launched against Jewish students maybe we'd get a few governors or the president saying something about it.
Permalink Zionism Is Not Judaism replied on
Can not quite put my finger on it but there is something inherently sleazy about the guy that makes the hairs on the back of ones neck stand up.
It is not just the hypocrisy, dishonesty, racism or the way he operates, but his smarmy oiliness. But hey if casino czar Shelly [Adelson] wasn't wasting his ill gotten Chinese gambling gains on Horrorwitz (and his corporate enslavement center) he might be spending it in more effective ways.
Just the same, all mentioned should take care. They do not want to suffer the same fate as the late Betty Van Patter (another "person of interest" for Horrorwitz).
Elaine Brown and the Panthers killed her my eye! More like another FBI Cointelpro operation "gone awry."
Anti-immigration groups and Israel
Permalink Antares replied on
It is always surprising to learn that anti-immigration groups can be pro-Israel.
Gee, I wonder who is pouring
Permalink sage24 replied on
Gee, I wonder who is pouring in millions of dollars for this hate campaign. We are fast becoming a nation that goes against the First Amendment of the Constitution.. Free speech is stifled for reasons that benefit some alien apartheid nation thousands of miles away. How convenient to link what is happening in the US to their criminal policies, and organize their thugs to attack our rights to free speech here. What is disappointing is that there are Americans here that go along with this.
What a putz
Permalink Skip Mendler replied on
What a putz David Horowitz is.
Horowitz is NOT a racist...
Permalink Binjamin Nuttyyahoo replied on
It's only racist if he's AGAINST Israel. The politically correct term for Pro-Israel "racism" is just "common sense" or "anti-terror".