Lobby Watch 23 February 2017
A conference on Israeli “exceptionalism” will go ahead in Ireland this spring, organizers insisted on Wednesday.
Supporters of the event – organized by University College Cork academics – include Ken Loach, director of the award-winning movie I, Daniel Blake, and Desmond Tutu, the South African archbishop.
The conference program was released this week. Richard Falk, a former UN special rapporteur on the occupied West Bank and Gaza, will give the keynote address.
Titled “International Law and the State of Israel: Legitimacy, Responsibility and Exceptionalism,” the conference was initially scheduled to take place at the UK’s University of Southampton in 2015.
But it was banned in the UK two years running, after the university came under intense pressure from government ministers and Israel lobby groups.
James Bowen, a professor in University College Cork and an organizer of the conference, told The Electronic Intifada that a venue had been secured.
He said that reports in The Irish Times last month that the conference had been canceled or postponed were false. An article about the conference was later altered, and the word “cancels” was removed from the headline.
Other speakers scheduled to participate in panels include Israeli historian Ilan Pappe; Palestinian author Ghada Karmi; Hatem Bazian from the University of California, Berkeley; noted Palestinian cartographer Salman Abu-Sitta and Israeli human rights lawyer Leah Tsemel.
Many of the speakers, including Karmi and Pappe, are noted supporters of a unitary democratic state for Palestinians and Israelis.
But the conference will also feature pro-Israel speakers Geoffrey Alderman and Alan Johnson. Alderman is a hard-right Zionist historian, while Johnson is senior research fellow for an Israel lobby group, the Britain Israel Communications and Research Centre.
Statements of support have been posted on the organizers’ website from Noam Chomsky, Desmond Tutu, philosopher Judith Butler, former British government minister Clare Short, journalist John Pilger, campaigning lawyer Michael Mansfield and filmmaker Ken Loach.
“This conference is all the more urgent given that Israel has continually broken international law with impunity,” Loach wrote. “The attacks on universities who wished to hold this conference make it all the more imperative that it should take place. It is the job of universities to defend academic freedom.”
The Board of Deputies of British Jews led the 2015 charge to have the conference banned in Southampton, claiming it was “an international gathering of anti-Zionists who were using the cover of a distinguished university to promote their view.”
The director of research at the university’s school of law wrote at the time that the cancellation occurred because of “the bullying and threats of the Israeli lobby” and that the university’s capitulation was “outrageous.”
Pro-Israel lobbyists claimed responsibility for having the original conference canceled, with one telling The Jewish Chronicle that the “health and safety” justification was a pretext.
The University of Southampton has refused to release correspondence with pro-Israel groups and others regarding the conference requested under the Freedom of Information Act by The Electronic Intifada.
The university claimed that releasing documents, even redacted, to a publication based in the United States would breach data protection provisions in UK law.
- Ken Loach
- University College Cork
- University of Southampton
- Archbishop Desmond Tutu
- Richard Falk
- James Bowen
- Ilan Pappe
- Ghada Karmi
- Hatem Bazian
- Salman Abu Sitta
- Leah Tsemel
- Geoffrey Alderman
- Alan Johnson
- Judith Butler
- Noam Chomsky
- Clare Short
- John Pilger
- Michael Mansfield
- Board of Deputies of British Jews
Permalink Sean Breathnach replied on
Congratulations to Cork for hosting this conference. Hope to be there.
a welcome occasion
Permalink tom hall replied on
I want to add my congratulations to the conference organisers and to the UCC administration. This will be a very important event.
Permalink John Costello replied on
"The university claimed that releasing documents, even redacted, to a publication based in the United States would breach data protection provisions in UK law."
I see, so I as an American, am specially exempted from passport requirements when travelling to the UK, and Israel soon, but my right's extending from our 1st amendment to the constitution can't go along. Have I got that right?
Passport exemptions, or any
Permalink James replied on
Passport exemptions, or any other for that matter, are a pleasantry. It's ridiculous to think that you travel the world under the Constitution of the United States. Even Americans have to obey the laws of the land that they are in. Believing & acting otherwise are not just trouble for the offender, it's also a smudge against the already murky image of the entire nation.
Permalink John Costello replied on
Yes, I see what you mean. That is a dumb thing to say or expect. What I was awkwardly referring to is the situation where our government agrees to onerous abridgments of civil rights, which we hold sacred, in agreements with other governments, such as special travel accommodations enjoyed by some and not others. The suggestion that Israelis should be able to travel to the US sans passport, while Americans would need one for Israel, is one example. I believe that motion failed but in the above case, the statute limiting a transfer of information between our countries, which enjoy a very tight alliance otherwise, seems a specious abridgment of the spirit of our commonality and law. It's an extra-constitutional betrayal of our mutually enjoyed civil rights.
Permalink Bunis Tuck replied on
Wonderful news...wish I could attend. Hope it will be videoed and available later..
Permalink Karenza-Monica Case replied on
I am overjoyed that this conference is taking place. Bravo University and Eire. Having been an occupied country for so long, Irish people will well understand the implications of occupation.
Anti Zionism is the ethical
Permalink Joe replied on
Anti Zionism is the ethical stance.
My wholehearted support to
Permalink Kraisak Choonhavan replied on
My wholehearted support to Cork university and the organizers of this very important conference.
President, Palestinian Solidarity Committee (PSC,Thailand)