Despite objections, Obama to allow notorious Israeli spy to go free

Israeli protesters urged Barack Obama to free convicted spy Jonathan Pollard, outside the hotel where the US president was staying during a visit to Jerusalem in March 2013.

Abir Sultan EPA

The Obama administration is denying that its decision to allow the release of a notorious spy is an effort to assuage Israel’s anger at the recent deal over Iran’s nuclear program.

Jonathan Pollard, a US naval intelligence officer, was arrested in 1985 and later sentenced to life in prison for passing the most sensitive and damaging US military and intelligence secrets to Israel in exchange for money to fund his luxurious lifestyle.

Israel is believed to have passed many of the most sensitive secrets to the Soviet Union, then the Cold War enemy of the US.

The damage Pollard did is so great that many senior officials believe he should never go free.

But last week, the US Department of Justice indicated that it would not oppose Pollard’s release at a mandatory parole hearing this week.

Pollard’s sentence is scheduled to end in a few months, but the government could have opposed parole if it deemed him a continuing threat to national security.

On Tuesday, it was announced that Pollard’s parole had been approved and he will go free in November, most likely moving to Israel.

White House officials insist that Pollard’s imminent release is not an attempt to “placate the Israelis in the wake of the Iran deal,” The New York Times reports.

But it is no secret that the Obama administration is making massive efforts to win support from members of Congress for the Iran deal.

If Congress passes a bill opposing the deal – as it is likely to do – the president needs at least one third of the members on his side to prevent Congress overriding his veto.

Among the measures Obama is already considering in an effort to win backing is a whopping 50 percent increase in US military aid to Israel.

Staunch opposition

There is no doubt that many senior figures in the political-military establishment, including staunch supporters of Israel, do see Pollard as an ongoing threat.

On Monday, Donald Rumsfeld, former US defense secretary during the first term of the George W. Bush administration, tweeted that “releasing Pollard was a bad idea in 1998 & 2001. It is not a better idea today.”

Rumsfeld, a key architect and perpetrator of the catastrophic US invasion of Iraq, also released a memo he had sent to President Bush on 16 March 2001, on the eve of a visit to Washington by then Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon.

The defense secretary told the president that the Israeli delegation would likely ask him to free Pollard.

“Any step to free Pollard would be enormously damaging to our efforts to keep spies out of our government,” Rumsfeld warned.

“Not no, but definitely no”

Rumsfeld reminded the president that CIA Director George Tenet had threatened to resign when it was suggested a few years earlier that President Bill Clinton might release Pollard. “I suspect he would feel the same today, and that there would be a number of others concerned about espionage who would feel the same.”

“My suggestion would be to come on very forcefully and say not no, but definitely no – no today, tomorrow and the next day,” Rumsfeld advised Bush. “The advantage of being forceful the first time they visit the subject is that it might set them back on their heels and give them pause about bringing the subject up to you ever again.”

Rumsfeld attached a letter opposing Pollard’s release, signed by seven former US secretaries of defense.

Rumsfeld, it should be recalled, is a staunch supporter of Israel; he explicitly backed its land grabs of Palestinian and Syrian land, which he referred to as “the so-called occupied territories.”

Unprecedented damage

That Rumsfeld and other top officials remain so adamant against the release of Pollard reflects how much damage they believe he did.

The full extent is unknown because Israel has refused to disclose to the United States government what it did with the information.

“It was the worst case that I have ever seen out of all the spy cases,” Ron Olive, the Navy counterintelligence officer who caught Pollard, told the BBC in 2012.

“Jonathan Pollard stole so many documents, so highly classified, more so than any other spy in the history of this country in such a short time,” Olive said.

Over 18 months, Pollard spirited highly classified US government documents to an apartment, where a secretary from the Israeli embassy would copy them before Pollard checked them back in.

Investigative journalist Seymour Hersh reported in 1999 that many US officials “strongly suspect that the Israelis repackaged much of Pollard’s material and provided it to the Soviet Union in exchange for continued Soviet permission for Jews to emigrate to Israel.”

Among the information Pollard stole was the top secret 10-volume National Security Agency manual describing how the United States obtained intelligence from all over the world. He also stole the information revealing how the US monitored the movement of Soviet nuclear-armed submarines.

Pollard is also believed to have exposed the names of US agents, almost certainly putting their lives at risk.

For love of money

In the decades he has been behind bars, Israeli leaders, especially the current Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, have demanded Pollard’s release, describing him as an Israeli national hero.

But Olive dismissed this: “What was motivating Jonathan Pollard was the number one thing that has motivated people to turn traitors and betray their country for decades and centuries: greed, money. And now though, now he pretends that it was for the love of Israel only, and now he has tens of thousands of supporters trying to get him out of jail.”

It was however, the decision of one man, President Barack Obama, that will finally set Pollard free.

Tags

Comments

picture

Meanwhile they don't allow Mordechai Vanunu to leave or speak about Dimona.

picture

He is not israeli.. He is Zionist yes, but he was born and raised and lived in the US.. makes him an american and a traitor

picture

While he is at it, why doesn't he set Leonard Peltier free.

picture

And Leonard Peltier was miles away when those two FBI goon provocateurs (who should not have been on Pine Ridge in the first place) was unjustly convicted by a kangaroo court presided over by an Indian hating racist troglodyte.

Since when has that ever stopped the US Misjustice Department meting out its nastiness.

Free Leonard Peltier Today!

picture

Pollard is only one of the spies who worked for Israel. In his book 'Foreign Agents' its author Grant Smith details how AIPAC operatives were indicted for espionage in 2005 and how AIPAC is the agent of a foreign government , and has violated public law in ways that seriously harms US national interests. Yet all US Presidents seem to act as lackeys to Israel, and bend over backwards to assuage Israel with huge additional arms supplies as a price tag for the US acting in its proper interests as in the new Iran deal. If Pollard is released it will be last straw -and Obama should insist that Vanunu and all Palestinians in administrative detention, and all leaders like Marwan Barghouti and Ahmed Sadat are released immediately.

picture

Many agree that Pollard did harm to the U.S., yet Obama is releasing him. [Why anyone seeks to appease the Israelis is beyond reason.] Obama is a hypocrite unless he releases the others mentioned in the previous comments. Moreover, Obama can and should pardon others who have done the world good by telling the truth...the heroic whistleblowers, Snowden and Manning, Americans of which our country can be proud.

Ali Abunimah

Ali Abunimah's picture

Co-founder of The Electronic Intifada and author of The Battle for Justice in Palestine, now out from Haymarket Books.

Also wrote One Country: A Bold-Proposal to End the Israeli-Palestinian Impasse. Opinions are mine alone.